Archive

United StatesPosts by

15 vs 14: Reading the Negotiating Geometry of the Two Hormuz Proposals

The United States 15-point proposal asks for the chokepoint as a status (reopening). The Iranian 14-point response asks for it as a structure (new mechanism). The two are mirror-image and the gap between them has, in principle, one institutional answer the existing chokepoint authorities at Suez and Panama have been operating for decades. This post reads the geometry of the gap and what fills it.

Read more →

Pakistan as Mediator: The Channel Through Which Both Hormuz Proposals Move

Pakistan brokered the 8 April ceasefire, hosted the Islamabad Talks of 10-11 April, and now carries the 14-point Iranian proposal and the United States response between Tehran and Washington. Pakistan also imports more than 85% of its crude through Hormuz. This post reads the mediation as institutional infrastructure of a temporary kind, identifies what the mediation can and cannot do, and explains where Pakistan would sit in any working chokepoint authority.

Read more →