Panama CanalPosts by

On 13 July 2026 Trump declared the US ‘Guardian of the Hormuz Strait’ and claimed a 20% toll on all cargo as ‘reimbursement’ for safety and security, reimposing the blockade and declaring the ceasefire over. This site judged Iran’s toll by four tests; intellectual honesty requires the same test here. The guardian’s toll fails all four, and worse: a non-riparian power, at 15x Iran’s rate, discriminatory by design. It is what tolling looks like when might replaces right, the clearest proof yet of what the institutional vacuum produces.

Suez and Panama are man-made canals that charge tolls for built infrastructure; Hormuz is a natural strait where UNCLOS permits only service fees, not passage tolls. There is no post-1945 precedent for a coastal state charging mandatory tolls on a natural strait. If Hormuz sets one, every chokepoint — Bab-el-Mandeb, Malacca, the South China Sea — becomes vulnerable. This post reads the precedent problem and why the service-fee distinction is the firewall.

Patrick Pouyanné, CEO of TotalEnergies, told the IMF/World Bank spring meetings that the industry would rather pay to transit Hormuz than face closure — citing Suez and Panama as precedents. He is the first supermajor CEO to publicly endorse the principle of a structured chokepoint toll.

On April 15 the President said the war was ‘close to over,’ the Pentagon said the blockade had ‘completely halted’ Iranian sea trade, and marine traffic data showed sanctioned tankers transiting Hormuz anyway. All three are true. The contradiction is the structural cost of doing without a neutral chokepoint authority.

On 6 April 2026, President Trump publicly endorsed the idea of charging tolls for Hormuz transit — the first sitting US president to do so. Iran is already improvising fees of $1M+ per ship. Both versions are unworkable. The Suez and Panama models show what a real chokepoint authority looks like.

The 2026 Strait of Hormuz crisis exposed three failures: no risk-pricing mechanism, no coordinated escort capacity, and no vessel prioritization. A structured toll model addresses each of them.